Blog / Enterprise

Read the headlines and you’d think CTV has finally caught up. Advanced audiences. Real-time decisioning. The right household at a competitive price. This past July, eMarketer reported that 93.8% of CTV ad spending now transacts programmatically.¹
Read past the headline, though, and there’s more nuance to unpack, because programmatic buying actually covers two distinct approaches. One means no auction at all, which strips out the precision and efficiency that made programmatic worth the name in the first place. The other keeps the decisioning in your hands, just exercised through a more private, closed-door deal with the publisher of your choice. In practice, the difference comes down to two deal types: private marketplace and programmatic guaranteed.
- Private marketplace (PMP): An invite-only deal with a publisher you chose, at rates you negotiated. Still biddable. Your algorithm decides impression by impression: bid, bid less, or pass entirely.
- Programmatic guaranteed (PG): Fixed price, fixed volume, committed in advance. Publishers require DSPs to bid on almost all bid requests. Limited advertiser choice and control.
Outside of sponsorships and tentpole events, most publishers now allow programmatic buying that is actually biddable, even against guaranteed spend commitments. The gap between PMP and PG isn’t inventory quality or premium access. It’s who controls the buy. Yet by some reports, only 25% of premium CTV is bought through PMPs.² We think it’s time for that to change.
How much decisioning power do you actually have?
On your last CTV buy, which of these did you decide: which household saw the ad, how many times, how recently, whether linear had already reached them, what data defined the audience, what that impression was worth, and whether to buy it at all?
On a PG deal, most of those sit with the seller. Choosing the publisher and negotiating a CPM is good planning, but it’s not advanced buying.
Without decisioning, you can’t bid intelligently toward the households you actually want. Heavy TV viewers absorb the majority of impressions, so they take the bulk of your budget by default, and you may miss out on reaching net-new households. You may buy three slots in the same program. That does nothing for the brand and nothing for efficiency. It just irritates someone who has already seen your ad.
This costs you in two ways: spend efficiency and customer experience. Omnicom Media Intelligence has a name for the tipping point: “negative reach,” the moment repeated impressions start frustrating people and damaging the brand instead of building it. More than 60% of consumers report seeing the same ad multiple times in a single streaming session. More than half say they would pay extra to avoid it.³
How PMPs deliver choice
- Household-level frequency across publishers, rather than a separate cap sitting in each publisher’s silo. This one depends entirely on durable household identity. Without it, cross-publisher frequency is an estimate dressed up as a control.
- Linear suppression, steering impressions away from homes your TV buy already reached and toward incremental CTV households.
- Algorithmic pricing, so the bid reflects what a given household is worth to you instead of one flat rate for every impression, regardless of how many times that household has seen your ad.
- Supply path optimization, choosing the cleanest route to the impression rather than inheriting whatever path the deal came with.
Customer success stories
One CPG advertiser made this shift to biddable supply and cut its CTV eCPM in half. Same advertiser, same brand, comparable premium-TV mix. The buying model was the variable.⁴ Another advertiser reached 60% more households for 32% less investment year over year. Same buy, same publisher mix, but with much greater control over frequency and the ability to suppress linear viewers.
An advertiser’s view
“We moved most of our CTV spend from PG to PMP last year, including our Upfront deals. PMPs have given us more control over which households we reach and how often across our entire campaign. That has made our spend work harder for us in terms of unique reach and incremental reach to linear. Our PMPs have actually paced more smoothly than our PG deals did, since we control daily, weekly, and monthly pacing, and we've still met our spend commitments with publishers. Apart from a few tentpole and live-sports buys, we're reaching the same premium inventory we had before. Our buying approach is really the only thing we changed."
- Mathew Sanders, VP Director, Platform Investment, Starcom
Where Yahoo DSP comes in
- More accurate household identification: Yahoo ConnectID now covers approximately 90% of CTV households, providing a stronger identity foundation for household-level targeting, reach, and frequency management.⁵
- Better cross-device and cross-publisher reach: ConnectID helps advertisers recognize and reach the same household across participating CTV publishers and devices, improving addressability, avoiding overexposure of households you've already reached, and redirecting spend toward net-new reach.
- Greater buyer control and transparency: PMP buying through Yahoo DSP gives advertisers centralized visibility and control over targeting, pacing, frequency, supply paths, and optimization instead of managing each publisher in a silo. Additionally, buyer controls that specifically solve for PMP buying:
- Mixed campaigns: Combine PG and PMP CTV lines in the same campaign, making it easier to manage and measure a broader CTV strategy in one place.
- Flexible Frequency Groups: Create custom frequency strategies across campaigns, packages, and lines; for example, separating CTV from non-CTV, managing PMP and PG independently, or setting different caps by brand or line of business.
- Peer39 CTV Quality Score: Analyze the quality of the CTV supply where your ads are served. Yahoo DSP has integrated Peer39’s CTV Quality Score, a unified metric built specifically for CTV measurement that’s calculated using a weighted blend of key signals, including completion rate, overnight impressions, and verified valid channels.
- Jounce Media Supply Insights: Access end-to-end supply chain reporting with detailed publisher and seller transparency, along with actionable SPO segments powered by Jounce’s market-leading supply path optimization insights, directly within the platform.
- Improved measurement: Unified TV reporting provides visibility into total, overlapping, and incremental reach and frequency across CTV supply sources and linear TV investments.
Don’t switch. Run the experiment.
PG has a real job: genuinely scarce inventory. Tentpoles, live sports, first position in pod. Guarantee those. Everything else should have to earn the impression. Our objection isn’t to PG. It’s to PG as a default, because a default is a decision nobody made.
Our suggestion: carve out 20% of your budget and test PG against PMP. Need help? Our Yahoo DSP teams are ready to assist.
Sources
¹eMarketer, US Programmatic Advertising Forecast and Ad Tech Trends H2 2026, Jul 2026
²Advertiser Perceptions, “CTV Landscape Report STREAMING TV, CTVDEVICES & DSPs, H1 2026
³ Omnicom Media Intelligence, Why Frequency Matters Combating Negative Reach, Apr 2026
⁴ Yahoo internal data, Aug 2026
⁵ Yahoo internal data, Q2 2026